Grisman sues…everyone

Grisman Music on iTunesWe recently told you about the law suit filed by David Grisman’s Dawg Music (Acoustic Disc) label against online video sharing site YouTube.com. It appears that’s not the only lawsuit he’s filed recently. He’s also suing Universal Music Group and Warner Music for contracting to sell his music online through digital download services without first consulting him, or paying the expected royalties.

What’s more, he’s extended the suit to include eight online download services which have distributed the music provided to them by Universal and Warner. The eight include Apple’s iTunes, AOL Music Now, Buy.com, Microsoft’s MSN.com, Napster, RealNetworks’ Rhapsody, WalMart.com, and Yahoo Music. He finds them guilty by association. That’s going to be a hard sell in my opinion because these services always pay to the label, who then distributes royalties to the artist. It seems to me his complaint should be with the two labels he signed contracts with to distribute his music.

The filing claims that “irreparable injury” has been done to Dawg Music by this situation and Grisman is seeking $150,000 for every work whose copyright was violated. Taken as a whole and spread across all the defendants, this would equal millions of dollars.

It seems Grisman has a contract with Universal and Warner, but his complaint is that they took on themselves authority that wasn’t granted to them by the contract. I’ve seen some pretty vague wording in some record contracts offered to artists by the labels that would give the label the right to “all future media” or some such. This could be one of the cases. I think Grisman needs to focus on his contract with the labels in question. I really don’t think he has any case against the online retail outlets.

1 Comment
Leave a comment
Comments are open and unmoderated for our registered users, only your first comment will require approval before publication. Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of The Bluegrass Blog. Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their content by The Bluegrass Blog.

comment #25989 By ryanfbaker on 05.25.07 12:05 pm

I wonder – did the concept of digital downloading exist when he signed the contract? All (or most) record company contracts do include the clause you mention, applying to something like “all media in existence now or in the future” for exactly this reason. What exactly did David think that meant? Enhanced CDs?

TrackBack URI

You must

  • Register
  • and Log in in to leave comments.

    Grisman sues YouTube

    In the first case I'm aware of involving a bluegrass artist, mandolinist David Grisman has filed suit...

    Legal music downloads and bluegrass

    The bluegrass music industry seems to find itself consistently behind the curve on technology, but more...

    MySpace faces legal battle over copyright issues

    This post is quite long. I've made an effort to present the facts of the legal battle. At the end of...

    SoundExchange Unpaid Artists and Labels

    SoundExchange is a nonprofit performance rights organization (PRO) jointly controlled by artists and...

    James Reams & The Barnstormers now available for download

    The new CD Troubled Times from James Reams & The Barnstormers is now available for legal download from...

    David Grisman Bluegrass Experience

    I just discovered a new release from David Grisman. It's The David Grisman Bluegrass Experience....

    Sell your video in iTunes with TuneCore

    It can be argued that a music video is a good promotional tool. And while that may be true, bluegrass...

    Self-produced CD – a brief diary from Chris Burton

    The following was contributed by Chris Burton, a good friend of The Bluegrass Blog. Knowing how many...

    Rural Rhythm embraces digital distribution

    Rural Rhythm Records has just announced the signing of a digital distribution agreement with existing...

    CDBaby Joins MP3 Revolution

    CDBaby has long been the entry point for independent artists longing for digital distribution. Creating...

    Music on memory cards

    Many have been wondering what is to become of the music industry with the seeming demise of the CD as...

    John Sebastian and David Grisman are Satisfied

    The newest release from David Grisman's Acoustic Disc label is a duo project featuring he and John Sebastian....