Does RollingStone know its Bluegrass?

Does RollingStone know its bluegrass?Does RollingStone know its bluegrass? Take a few minutes to read this article, recently published on the magazine’s website, and then answer in our poll.

Here’s the introduction.

It’s been more than 60 years since Bill Monroe, the Father of Bluegrass, unleashed the genre on the world with his Kentucky band the Blue Grass Boys. But a new crop of acts are paying tribute to the style, updating the old-time-and-country-music hybrid with contemporary rock and pop styles. Below are five acts to watch with commentary from bluegrass legends Del McCoury and Sam Bush:

The article, titled The New Bluegrass: Five Acts to Watch, presents a short profile of five bands RollingStone thinks are the up and coming face of “new bluegrass,” whatever that means. The five bands are: O’Death, Avett Brothers, Uncle Earl, Those Darlins, and Old Crow Medicine Show.

I don’t think these are the bands I would have picked.

How about you? Do you think Rolling Stone knows what it’s talking about?

[poll:14]

7 Comments
Leave a comment
Comments are open and unmoderated for our registered users, only your first comment will require approval before publication. Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of The Bluegrass Blog. Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their content by The Bluegrass Blog.

comment #55787 By americanaproud on 04.15.09 1:05 pm

Couldn’t take the poll without commenting:

Although these are all wonderful groups with their own unique sounds and styles, they are certainly by no means the future of Traditional Bluegrass, and are only one small part of the entire Contemporary side of the genre.

As always, it will be the fans who ultimately decide who to like and keep their collective eye on. Who would have thought two years ago, for instance, that two long time sidemen getting together (Dailey and Vincent), would be the talk of the IBMA, and such a hit with the fans.

On the plus side, it’s good to know that RollingStone at least knows Bluegrass exists!

comment #55789 By Archie on 04.15.09 3:16 pm

Well, I voted “yes.” The hedge is the quote the up and coming face of new bluegrass. I’ll accept the characterization of these bands with that precondition.
They specifically didn’t ask about the future of traditional bluegrass. Anyway, five bands, no matter how selected, will inevitably be one small part of the bluegrass spectrum.

[...] Bluegrass Blog has alerted us to an amount of controversy that has set in over  an article posted on the Rolling [...]

[...] The Bluegrass Blog polled its readers to find out whether they think Rolling Stone knows its bluegrass or not. Of the 432 readers who [...]

comment #55798 By aburtch on 04.16.09 1:48 pm

Any coverage is good coverage so I would say the answer is yes. We need articles like this in mainstream press to keep our music in the public eye. You have to remember only bluegrass people argue about what bluegrass is or isn’t. To casual fans, anything acoustic with a banjo sounds like bluegrass to them. And to give RS credit, other than omitting the Infamous Stringdusters, those are some good bands they picked.

[...] out the Bluegrass Blog Post to vote on whether you think these choices are appropriate and if you think RollingStone knows its [...]

comment #58644 By countryst on 10.23.09 1:07 am

There are reviews of the Avett Brothers’ concert in Boston on Sunday and their CD, “I and Love and You,” at Country Standard Time’s website: http://www.countrystandardtime.com

TrackBack URI

You must

  • Register
  • and Log in in to leave comments.

    Warren Haynes’ bluegrass past

    Rolling Stone Magazine has listed Warren Haynes as 23rd on their list of the 100 Greatest Guitarists of All Time. While I would contend that the title of that list should be amended to the 100 Greatest Rock Guitarists of All Time, and even then it could be disputed (by those concerned with the genre),...

    Uncle Earl at Bonnaroo

    We've just learned that bluegrass/old-time band Uncle Earl will be performing at the 2007 Bonnaroo music festival. The festival takes place mid June in Manchester, TN and has become a large and very popular festival in the last few years. Bonnaroo primarily books rock, alternative (to what?), and...

    Del McCoury interview in Fly Magazine

    Fly Magazine is the local dining and entertainment magazine for the Lancaster, York, and Harrisburg PA areas. That area is actually home to Del McCoury and the December issue is featuring an interview with Del. The article refers to Del as possibly the "world's first 70-year-old rock star." They then...

    IBMA Gig Fair

    This morning IBMA sponsored their Gig Fair, where bands had an opportunity for brief, one-on-one meetings with representatives from more than 30 major festivals and concert series. Though bands had been able to pre-set appointments in advance, anyone who attended could meet with the promoters on a round...

    Uncle Earl moving up the chart

    Uncle Earl, the all-female old time band making such a splash at bluegrass festivals this summer, is featured in the Breaking & Entering column in the August 10 edition of Billboard magazine. This recurring feature offers a glimpse at acts breaking into radio or retail, or entering the Billboard charts...

    Scruggs videos at Gibson.com

    There are six short videos up on Gibson's web site that feature banjo legend Earl Scruggs discussing his life and career in bluegrass and acoustic music. It seems that they were all recorded earlier this year. Each of the links below go to one of the individual video clips, each focusing on a specific...

    Bluegrass Bands Gather for Special Fan

    Great Article! Just wanted to make a small correction. The bands playing on August 6th will only be the Little Mountain Boys, Nothin' Fancy, Larry Stephenson and Rhonda Vincent. The other bands mentioned as well as several others played a benefit concert on July 26th for Mary....

    Beatles tribute album – This Bird Has Flown

    This Bird Has Flown is a tribute album to the 40th anniversary of The Beatles' Rubber Soul. The CD contains all the songs the Rubber Soul album contained in the same sequence. The difference is the performances are all from various artists in various genres. The only bluegrass representation on the record...

    Jerusalem Ridge Bluegrass Celebration 2006

    Jerusalem Ridge Bluegrass Celebration '06! I can't find adequate words to describe the aura that surrounded this wonderful event! Taking place on "Ground Zero" for bluegrass music, the birthplace of Bill Monroe, the Jerusalem Ridge Bluegrass Celebration is fast becoming "THE" bluegrass festival of...

    Nashville Scene highlights bluegrass acts

    The Nashville Scene is a weekly paper published locally in Nashville, TN. The paper features articles and stories as well as performance schedules for all the venues in and around Nashville. They recently published an article entitled Our Critics Picks. That article is now available online at their website....

    Bonnaroo fest streaming video at AT&T blueroom

    The AT&T blueroom is offering a live video stream from the Bonnaroo festival this weekend (6/15/17) online. You can see the performance schedule they will carry on the Bonnaroo site. This isn't a bluegrass event by any stretch, but a number of acts are slated to appear who may be of interest to...

    IBMA Showcase acts for 2006 announced

    The International Bluegrass Music Association has announced the showcase acts for 2006 World Of Bluegrass. These acts will perform before the decision makers in bluegrass music, expected to include more than 2,000 music industry professionals from all over the world when the convention and trade show...