Award Show Thoughts

viewpointLast evenings award show brought a few surprises, to most of us I’m sure. Of course the big surprise was Cherryholmes winning Entertainer Of The Year. I’m glad they won, though I had really expected them to win Emerging Artist Of The Year, as did the readers who voted in our poll. My last post was a side by side comparison of the official winners and our poll winners. We’ve talked to a lot of people who have expressed surprise, and in some cases delight, over the awards. We received one email from a reader who did a great job of expressing his view of the awards. Here is his email:

The selections of Cherryholmes, Phil Ledbetter twice, and Bryan Sutton for major awards by the members of IBMS says a great deal about their commitment to the future. Awards ceremonies like the Academy Awards, The Emmies, the Grammies, and CMA frequently take the easy road by giving major awards to performers whose best work is in the past and, they believe, deserve to be recognized by their industry for past accomplishments.

IBMA members have taken a very different approach. They have said that bluegrass music is a young, vigorous, growing form that must reach out to a young audiences with music that appeals to them. At the same time, they continue to honor bluegrass tradtions by giving major awards to Ricky Skaggs and Doyle Lawson.

Few people would argue that Bela Fleck and Jerry Douglas are not the foremost masters of their instruments. They have received recognition for their work and the continued adulation of the bluegrass community. By awarding Jim Mills and Phil Ledbetter, the members of IBMA have said that the world of bluegrass is broad and includes many important musicians beyond the easy choices.

The variance between the awards actually given and those voted for in the Bluegrass Blog poll suggest that IBMA members are more forward looking than the fans voting in the popularity contest sponsored by this blog. That’s an interesting outcome that in no way diminishes the important contribution made by bluegrass blog.

Ted Lehmann

So, share with us your thoughts and opinions of last night’s awards. Please remember that John and I are on site at the IBMA Fan Fest, therefore comment moderation may be delayed slightly.

2 Comments
Leave a comment
Comments are open and unmoderated for our registered users, only your first comment will require approval before publication. Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of The Bluegrass Blog. Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their content by The Bluegrass Blog.

comment #101 By Patricia Curtis on 11.01.05 12:47 am

Question: Who are the board members of the IBMA, how long are their terms, and who appoints them? I can’t locate them on the IBMA website and find that interesting. Could we have names, please?

comment #102 By John Lawless on 11.01.05 7:56 am

I also looked for that info yesterday on the IBMA web site, and was surprised that I couldn’t turn it up. I’m sure that a call to IBMA’s offices (most probably unattended this next few days) would get you this information.

There is nothing secretive about the organization, and it seems like making the names of the staff and the board members available online would be a good idea.

TrackBack URI

You must

  • Register
  • and Log in in to leave comments.

    Bluegrass Blog Reader Award Poll: Update 9/14

    With IBMA fast approaching, and the official awards soon to be handed out, don't forget to vote in our...

    Awards Poll Update – 9/25/06

    World of Bluegrass week has begun and so this will be the last Awards Poll update before the actual awards...

    Awards Poll Update – 9/18/06

    Here we are one week away from the IBMA World of Bluegrass. So this is to be our next-to-last update...

    2009 Bluegrass Blog Awards

    It's official! OK, not really. But our 2009 Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll is officially open. The...

    2008 Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll

    Just for fun we decided to run an Awards Poll again this year. Like previous years, it mirrors the...

    The Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll 2005 – Update

    Friday Update - If you haven't already voted in our unofficial awards poll, we encourage you do so. The...

    The Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll 2006

    Just as we did last year, The Bluegrass Blog is hosting an online poll that mirrors the final IBMA Awards...

    Awards Poll Update – 9/11/06

    Here's this week's update and report on the ongoing Awards Poll. Last week just over 10% of the registered...

    Awards Poll Update – 10/26

    Only 1 day left to vote! We'll be closing the poll tomorrow at noon. If you wish to participate please...

    Format for awards announcements

    As each award is announced, we will post the name of the recipient, along with the winner of our reader-driven...

    Bluegrass Blog Reader Award Poll: Update 10/1

    IBMA begins today, and the official Awards Show is only 3 days away. Here's an update on our reader poll,...

    The Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll – still voting

    The Bluegrass Blog Awards Poll 2005 remains open to registered users until Thursday Oct. 27 at noon....